Afghanistan’s Political Legitimacy Requires Public Consent, Inclusive Governance and Accountability

The Taliban regime’s reported gathering at Kabul University to endorse Sheikh Hibatullah Akhundzada highlights the importance of distinguishing genuine political legitimacy from orchestrated displays of support. Bringing together selected religious scholars and presenting their endorsements as a national mandate cannot replace the consent of the Afghan people. Legitimate governance must be rooted in public participation, justice, accountability and representative political institutions.

The reported suspension of academic activities and removal of students from university accommodation to facilitate the gathering raises further concerns about the politicisation of educational institutions. Universities should serve as centres of learning, independent thought and intellectual development, not platforms for political messaging. Similarly, religious scholarship should remain grounded in independent deliberation rather than being reduced to an exercise in political endorsement.

The reported emphasis on personal obedience to the supreme leader also raises fundamental questions about governance and accountability. Islamic principles of consultation (Shura), justice and collective responsibility provide an important framework for political leadership. Religious authority cannot be treated as a substitute for public consent, nor should loyalty to an individual be equated with loyalty to Islam or Afghanistan.

Meanwhile, reported differences within the Taliban leadership, including criticism of policies associated with Kandahar, underscore the challenges of maintaining political cohesion through centralised authority. These developments reinforce the need for institutional accountability and meaningful political dialogue rather than personality-driven governance.

The positions articulated by Afghanistan’s opposition movements, including the Islamic Society of Afghanistan and the National Resistance Front, point towards a broader debate about the country’s political future. Their calls for nationwide elections, equal citizenship, the rule of law and inclusive political participation highlight the need for a system in which all Afghans can have a meaningful voice. Sustainable political stability cannot emerge from symbolic power-sharing arrangements or the redistribution of positions within an existing ruling structure.

For Afghanistan to move towards lasting peace and stability, its political future must be determined through an inclusive and credible process that reflects the aspirations of its people. Meaningful representation, equal rights, institutional accountability and public consent are essential foundations of legitimate governance. No staged gathering or selective endorsement can replace the Afghan people’s right to determine their own political future.

Share it :